Tuesday, July 26, 2016

Annals of "bullshit" rankings

Rankings are fun, sure, but it's good to figure out wheter the metric means something (anything!) lest one produce nonsense.  Case in point:  ranking law reviews by Google Scholar h-indices.  The problem (we've encountered it in philosophy in the past, but now everyone there knows Google  Scholar is worthless for measuring journal impact) is that there is no control for the volume of publishing by each journal, so any journal that publishes more pages and articles per year will do better than a peer journal with the same actual impact that publishes fewer articles and pages.

UPDATE:  In the case of philosophy, Synthese was the number 1 journal in "impact" according to the nonsense Google number--this was obviously ludicrous, as everyone in academic philosophy knew.  But Synthese also publishes five to ten times as many articles per year as the actual leading journals in the field.  One philosopher adjusted the results for volume of publication, and lo and behold, Synthese rank fell dramatically.

July 26, 2016 in Rankings | Permalink

Monday, July 25, 2016

Most-Cited lists: what's coming

Two more subject-matter areas:  Family Law and Legal Ethics/Legal Profession/Professional Responsibility.  And then a list of schools by the per capita rate at which their tenured faculty made one of the many most-cited lists.   I should have these lists out by mid-August at the latest.

July 25, 2016 in Faculty News, Rankings | Permalink

Sunday, July 24, 2016

Lateral hires with tenure or on tenure-track, 2015-16

THIS IS THE LAST TIME I AM MOVING THIS TO THE FRONT FOR THE PAST HIRING SEASON--THE 2016-17 INITIAL LIST WILL APPEAR HERE ON AUGUST 1

These are non-clinical appointments that will take effect in 2016 (except where noted); I will move the list to the front at various intervals as new additions come in.   Recent additions are in bold. Last year's list is here.   

 

*Edward Afield (tax) from Ava Maria School of Law to Georgia State University.

 

*Lisa Alexander (corporate, contracts, housing & urban development law) from the University of Wisconsin, Madison to Texas A&M University.

 

*Mark Alexander (constitutional law, law & politics) from Seton Hall University to Villanova University (to become Dean).

 

*James Anaya (international human rights) from the University of Arizona to the University of Colorado, Boulder (to become Dean).

 

*RonNell Anderson (constitutional law, First Amendment, media law) from Brigham Young University to the University of Utah.

 

*Margo Bagley (patents, international patent law) from the University of Virginia to Emory University.

 

*Craig Boise (tax, international tax, corporate tax) from Cleveland-Marshall College of Law, Cleveland State University to Syracuse University (to become Dean).

 

*Zack Buck (health law) from Mercer University to the University of Tennessee, Knoxville (untenured lateral).

 

*Michael Cahill (criminal law) from Brooklyn Law School to Rutgers University (as Co-Dean).

 

*Dale Carpenter (constitutional law) from the University of Minnesota to Southern Methodist University.

 

*James Coleman (energy law) from the University of Calgary to Southern Methodist University (untenured lateral).

 

*Nicolas Cornell (contracts, law & philosophy) from the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania to the University of Michigan (law) (untenured lateral) (starting in fall 2017).

 

*Eric Dannenmaier (environmental law) from Indiana University, Indianapolis to Northern Illinois University (to become Dean). 

Continue reading

July 24, 2016 in Faculty News | Permalink

Friday, July 22, 2016

Revenge porn law introduced in Congress

An important milestone; law professor Mary Anne Franks (Miami), the primary author of the bill, is quoted in the article.

(Thanks to Jason Walta for the pointer.)

UPDATE:  An op-ed by Prof. Franks about the law.  If there is, in fact, a successful First Amendment challenge to the law, it would just be a further indication of how wrong U.S. free speech doctrine is in important respects.

July 22, 2016 in Law in Cyberspace, Of Academic Interest | Permalink

Thursday, July 21, 2016

Ten Most-Cited Antitrust Faculty, 2010-2014 (inclusive)

  Once again, this draws on the data from the 2015 Sisk study:    

Rank

Name

School

Citations

Age in 2016

1

Herbert Hovenkamp

University of Iowa

1070

68

2

Daniel Crane

University of Michigan

  400

46

3

William Kovacic

George Washington University

  390

64

 

Joshua Wright

George Mason University

  390

39

5

Michael Carrier

Rutgers University (Camden)

  370

47

6

Christopher Leslie

University of California, Irvine

  340

52

 

Daniel Rubinfeld

New York University

  340

71

8

C. Scott Hemphill

New York University

  310

43

9

Spencer Waller

Loyola University, Chicago

  280

59

10

Timothy Muris

George Mason University

  250

67

   

Runners-up for the top ten

   
 

Jonathan Baker

American University

  240

61

 

Fred McChesney

University of Miami

  240

68

 

William Page

University of Florida

  240

65

   

Other highly-cited scholars who work partly in this area

   
 

Mark Lemley

Stanford University

2400

50

 

Louis Kaplow

Harvard University

1150

60

 

Einer Elhauge

Harvard University

  680

55

 

George Priest

Yale University

  570

63

 

Keith Hylton

Boston University

  440

56

 

July 21, 2016 in Faculty News, Rankings | Permalink

Wednesday, July 20, 2016

Obligations of law faculty to disclose research supported by those with a stake in the findings?

Prof. Jeff Sovern (St. John's) writes:

I have been wondering about the extent of law professors’ ethical obligations to disclose when their research has been supported by a grant from a group with a stake in the findings, and because you are the de facto moderator of the law professor village square, I wondered if you would consider posting the item below to your blog and seeking comment. I apologize for its length.

 

A grant that results in the publication of a law review article or similar publication should be acknowledged in the article, but what about later work in the same general area that espouses a policy position consistent with what the grantor would have wanted? That issue is germane to a 2013 article in The Nation, The Scholars Who Shill for Wall Street which criticized academics (notably, George Mason’s Todd Zywicki) for failing to disclose in papers, congressional testimony, speeches, op-eds, etc. compensated work for the financial industry.  The AALS has been rather vague on this subject, but here’s what it said in its Statement of Good Practices by Law Professors in the Discharge of Their Ethical and Professional Responsibilities: “Sponsored or remunerated research should always be acknowledged with full disclosure of the interests of the parties. If views expressed in an article were also espoused in the course of representation of a client or in consulting, this should be acknowledged.” It’s not at all clear to me that the conduct described in The Nation article violated that policy.

 

My own concern is more personal.  My law school (St. John’s) accepted a grant from an organization with ties to a particular industry.  My co-authors and I conducted a survey financed by this grant (we had to purchase a software license, compensate those who completed the survey, and so on) and published a law review article about our findings.  We had complete control over the survey and what we wrote about our findings and the grantor did not comment on them; in all respects, its behavior was exemplary.  We acknowledged the funder in the article.  Later, I wrote some op-eds about our work, and acknowledged the grantor again.  Still later, I wrote op-eds about the broader subject, giving no more than a sentence to our research, or not mentioning it at all. Do I have an obligation in the later op-eds to mention the grantor?  Would readers want to know that my law school accepted money from the grantor which supported my research?  If your answer is no, do you see anything wrong with the conduct described in The Nation article?  If you answer is yes, would it be different if the funder were not associated with a particular industry or point of view?

 

Perhaps the AALS would consider updating and elaborating on its statement.  It might be a good project for professors specializing in professional responsibility. When the AALS re-evaluates a school for membership every seven years, does it inquire into compliance with this aspect of its Statement of Good Practices?  Should it? 

Good questions, I've opened it for comments.  (Submit your comment only once, comments are moderated, and may take awhile to appear.)

July 20, 2016 in Legal Profession, Of Academic Interest, Professional Advice | Permalink | Comments (1)

Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Hiring committees can announce themselves...

...and their curricular priorities here.

July 19, 2016 in Advice for Academic Job Seekers, Of Academic Interest | Permalink

Monday, July 18, 2016

A first sign of trouble with the new Elsevier-owned SSRN

Ten Most-Cited Torts/Products Liability/Insurance Law Faculty, 2010-2014 (inclusive)

 Once again, this draws on the data from the 2015 Sisk study:   

 

Rank

Name

School

Citations

Age in 2016

1

John C.P. Goldberg

Harvard University

  550

55

2

Benjamin Zipursky

Fordham University

  470

56

3

Tom Baker

University of Pennsylvania

  450

57

4

Robert Rabin

Stanford University

  410

77

5

Catherine Sharkey

New York University

  400

46

6

Kenneth Abraham

University of Virginia

  350

70

7

Anita Bernstein

Brooklyn Law School

  290

55

 

Stephen Sugarman

University of California, Berkeley

  290

74

9

David Rosenberg

Harvard University

  270

73 (est.)

10

Michael Green

Wake Forest University

  240

66

   

Other highly-cited scholars who work partly in these areas

   
 

Richard Epstein

New York University; University of Chicago

2680

73

 

Steven Shavell

Harvard University

1340

70

 

Saul Levmore

University of Chicago

  550

63

 

Keith Hylton

Boston University

  440

56

July 18, 2016 in Faculty News, Rankings | Permalink

Tuesday, July 12, 2016

Penn Law (joint with Political Science) hires leading international affairs and human rights scholar Beth Simmons from Harvard

Penn's press release.

July 12, 2016 in Faculty News | Permalink