Brian Leiter's Law School Reports

Brian Leiter
University of Chicago Law School

A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Monday, March 12, 2007

More on the Ciolli/Cohen "Discussion" Board: Penn and Yale Law Deans Speak Out

A follow-up story in The Washington Post to the earlier item on the "law school" discussion board run by Anthony Ciolli, a law student at Penn, and Jarret Cohen, an insurance salesman:

The deans at two top law schools have admonished the operators of an Internet message board that hosts chats containing personal attacks against female students and racist and homophobic remarks. Letters written by the deans at Yale University and the University of Pennsylvania law schools, were issued after an article in The Washington Post aired the debate over AutoAdmit, a message board that was created as a forum to exchange advice on law schools and firms....

In an open letter to the "Yale Law School Community," Dean Harold Koh noted that AutoAdmit contained numerous "false and hurtful assertions" by anonymous posters, and that some included names and personal information of Yale students.

Some chats contained claims that women had sexually transmitted diseases. One Yale student, The Post reported, believed that the chat content, which was accessible in a Google search, contributed to her inability to find a summer job.

"Such anonymous, personal attacks on individuals are despicable," Koh wrote. "These malicious attacks, as well as racist, sexist and homophobic speech, have no place in the Yale Law School community."

The Penn law school dean, Michael A. Fitts, and the associate dean, Gary Clinton, posted a letter on the site Thursday, stating that while they understood the right to engage in spirited debate, "we all have a moral and professional obligation to engage in that debate in a responsible manner."

They said that though the university thought it had no basis to act against Ciolli, the derogatory comments could serve as a basis for defamation suits and "may increasingly become the subject of concern by bar admissions committees."

Meanwhile, ReputationDefender, which is representing several women who were targeted on AutoAdmit, has engaged a law firm to explore civil and criminal claims on the women's behalf, ReputationDefender chief executive Michael Fertik said.

Apparently, Google has withdrawn its ads from the site and the site's current service provider is withdrawing its services, since the site's content violates its policies.

UPDATE:  Still more commentary here (with many links).

http://leiterlawschool.typepad.com/leiter/2007/03/more_on_the_cio.html

Of Academic Interest, Student Advice | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c659b53ef00d8354127e053ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference More on the Ciolli/Cohen "Discussion" Board: Penn and Yale Law Deans Speak Out: